You Will Never Find A Personal Stylist service With A Subscription Box

Thinking Of Booking A Personal Stylist Service In A Prescription Box?

Think again. If you have been looking for the best personal stylist service subscription box, read this before you decide. Over the last few years, several subscription services have cropped up, offering a range of niche services. For as little as £10 a month, the subscription boxes are advertised as providing ‘Personal Styling For Women And Men’ or ‘Get clothing hand-selected by our expert stylists’. It sounds like a good deal right? I mean, who would not want their own personal stylist for £10 a month?


Having spent 22 years working as a personal stylist with celebrities and personal clients worldwide, let me explain why.

You Get What You Pay For

If something looks like it is too good to be true, it usually is. Considering a personal service should not look like that, whatever kind of service it is. When you purchase, you pay for the experts time and experience. That experience means that you get what you pay for. Whether it be a hairstylist, a dressmaker, a photographer or a personal stylist, it takes years of experience to gain that title. Anyone can say they are any one of these experts, but unfortunately, they will not deliver the goods.

Personal stylists, like any expert, will often have studied their craft at university and then spent years working their way up in their field. That experience of working their way up is where they learn their true craft. Working with different clients from different backgrounds, with various budgets and timescales, means they can deliver what the clients want. A professional stylist will learn the tiny nuances of two clients with the same body shape and how to assess a person’s size by just looking at them or knowing from experience what colours will suit them. None of this expertise can be taught in a few weeks. It comes from real life, in-person experience.

To apply to be a ‘personal stylist’ at any number of the popular subscription box services, you need NONE of that experience. Check out their application pages yourself, and you will see requirements like ‘you are passionate about fashion’ and ‘you like to inspire clients to try out new trends’. So essentially, the ‘personal stylists’ do not need ANY experience when they start.


Does that not seem a little odd to you? How can you gain real experience as a personal stylist when you work from home?


Believe me; you can’t.

Woman Of Colour With Sunglasses on

So What Do You Get With A Personal Stylist Subscription Box?

Well, one thing you do not get is a personal stylist choosing the outfits for you, whatever it says on the description. Just to clarify, I have no problem with the people who work for any of the subscription box services; I am sure they are good at what they do. However, I do have a problem with the companies tricking the public into thinking they are getting a service they are not.

Recently, I highlighted this with Stitchfix on social media. I put it to them that the people choosing the clothes were not personal stylists because they did not have the experience of a personal stylist, so it was false advertising to claim they were. I told them that a person trained to use an algorithm was not a personal stylist. I said that no personal stylist would work for £10 an hour because the experience they bring to the client is worth much more. They skirted around my statement by answering that the ‘stylists certainly are real people’ and that ‘I could see more about them here’ where they included a link. If you look on Stitch Fix’s website and go to ‘Careers’ and ‘See All Openings’, you will see the first, and one of the largest sections is titled ‘Algorithums’. 


Now my question to you is this;


If personal stylists choose the clothes, why do they need such large teams dedicated to algorithms? 


When you sign up for a fashion subscription box, you fill out a series of questions. Those questions go into a system where algorithms filter out suggestions for you. Next, a person who is trained to use the system chooses an outfit from those suggestions and arranges to have them sent out to you. 


That is why it never quite feels right. An algorithm is taking the answers to your questions and filtering what you should have.


That is not a personal stylist. 


So when you sign up for a subscription box, for ten pounds a month, you get an algorithm and a person trained to use it choosing your clothes. 

So What Should You Look For In A Personal Stylist Service?

First, look for real-world experience. A good personal stylist service provider will have a minimum of five years of experience behind them dressing clients in person in various situations and backgrounds. Ask them about previous clients, check to see if they have any testimonials. If they do, you could even ask if you could contact one of them. Look for any published work either online or in hard copy. Check out independently where their experience lies by doing some searches away from the website. A personal stylist service provider with decent experience will have references of work elsewhere online. Look for experience in a variety of backgrounds. If they have gained their experience working in a store, that is pretty limited. Variety is key. 

If you are looking for a genuine personal stylist, you should NOT settle for anything less.

Alternatively, if you can not get to the shops to talk to an experienced shop assistant, or do not have the budget, try out a subscription box, but go into it knowing full well what you are signing up for. Alternatively, check out the capsule closet stylist membership where you do get regular access to a professional stylist  for a small monthly fee. If you are a man looking for help with your wardrobe you can get help here

What Next?

The information given in the post is the best of my knowledge at the time of writing. If you are embarking on anything new get professional advice if required.

If you enjoyed this post and wish to create a capsule wardrobe, I can help you create one quickly and easily. Get started immediately with one of my personal styling services or book in for a complimentary consultation

  • Personal Styling Gift Vouchers – Save up, ask for them for gifts or put towards any of my services. This is the ideal way to afford a personal stylist whatever your budget!
  • Capsule Closet Success Membership – Receive a copy of the Seasonal Capsule Essentials Ebook twice a year worth $19 and gain access to the Capsule Closet Success Course worth $200. Join our private community for support and advice and submit questions every week and have them answered live in our weekly live check-in sessions. 
  • Premium Personal Styling – A personalised colour analysis and body shape style guide, a live wardrobe edit, a personal shopping and a curated Lookbook
  • Personal Styling – 
  • A personalised Colour Analysis, a Body Shape Analysis And Style Guide, a Live Wardrobe Edit
  • A wardrobe Edit – A 20-minute zoom call to discuss your needs and to highlight any particular problems you want to address in the wardrobe edit. A private Pinterest board to pin styles and colours you love. A 60 minutes live video wardrobe edit
  • Colour Analysis And Body Shape Styling –
  • The Capsule Closet Stylist Colour Analysis looks at the natural colouring in your hair, eyes and skin tone and shows how you can complement your natural colouring in your clothes. The Body Shape Style Guide teaches you how to make the most of your best assets, hide what you do not like, find clothes that complement your shape, and choose the perfect fit.

Still Not Sure?

Book a discovery call with me where we can discuss colour, style, decluttering, body shapes and much, much more.  I can identify where you most need help and point you in the right direction. 

**Please Note This Post Contains Affiliate Links

Capsule Closet Stylist is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Program, Shopstyle and LTK, affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for sites to earn commission incomes by advertising and linking to 

Why not join my facebook community  of other people on a similar journey.

Or follow me on Youtube or Instagram

for lots of videos and image inspiration. 

Love a freebie? Sign up for my Capsule Wardrobe Guide Worth $40

I will send you lots of tips on creating the perfect wardrobe. I am a minimalist, so I promise I will not be bombarding you with emails. 

If you would like to support the show and help me create more content, you can do so here. Thank you in advance

Leave a Reply

More Articles

If you would like to support the blog and help me create more content, you can do so here. Thank you in advance

Download my FREE Capsule Wardrobe Planner Worth $40!!

Capsule Closet Success testimonials

'When you join the membership it isn't generic it is tailored to your needs. Michelle considers each individual person and provides advice and guidance based on their needs. I have learnt so much since I joined I feel like I could sit an exam on it now! Honestly, without a doubt if you feel like you are lost with what to wear, you don't know what suits your body shape or your shape has changed, you've lost confidence, you're starting a new job, or you want to minimise your wardrobe, Michelle's membership is without a doubt for you. You can not get better for the price, I have looked!'
I joined Michelle's facebook "capsule wardrobe challenge" in June 2020. I loved her approach of starting off with a concept of what colours and styles you were attracted to, followed by what your lifestyle required functionally. It helped me assess my existing wardrobe with a checklist in mind instead of feeling overwhelmed and indecisive. I found the video format and weekly check-ins easy to follow and explained each stage of building a capsule well. She has been quick to answer any queries I have and to offer her professional stylist's opinion with a gentle manner. I am most grateful for Michelle's overarching aim to help her clients "find their happy place". This membership is about being comfortable in your own skin, not about being super fashionable, and that is exactly what I needed. Thank you for helping me find my confidence again. 😊
There is no doubt in my mind that having a personal stylist online is worth the investment. In fact, at the end of the day I will spend considerably less while looking and feeling so much better. Why? Because I will never again mindlessly spend and spend and spend on clothes that just aren’t right for me and that don’t make me happy. I think we all dream of that wardrobe that makes us happy and confident, but it is so easy to just give up and just wear something. I know I did. And that is just plain crazy because I love clothes! I have always been attracted to styles that I lacked the confidence to try out. Now, with the help and guidance of Michelle, I can finally explore those styles with confidence knowing that whenever I run an item by Michelle, she will give me her honest feedback on whether or not it will fit with my colors and with how I want to look and feel. In short: Michelle’s advice really is priceless. I feel an A-lister in the garments I have purchased since becoming a member! Pssst: One secret, you don’t have to become a minimalist if you don’t want to. Michelle is not about legalistic minalism, she is all about you finding out what works for you and that – along with her very deep knowledge of style – is why I think her membership works for me when in the past nothing else has.

The Capsule Wardrobe Guide

Build a capsule wardrobe like a pro

Receive the latest news and FREE articles. 

woman holding clothes up looking happy
Subscribe & Get For A Limited Time Only!

10% off on Your First Purchase